I meant to make this earlier in the merge like I typically do, but we're not doing an All Star season like we typically do so it didn't matter as much

Instead of doing about five more regular seasons and then another AS season, we've decided to take an approach more like the show does. We'll do however many 'regular' seasons we want, and then maybe an All Stars, another FvF, a HvV, a second chance season, etc. Personally, we enjoy this way far more

This means we won't be naming seven or so specific All Stars when this season ends, like usual. When another returnee or All Star season rolls around eventually, we'll name the cast around that time and choose whoever we feel is worthy and available, same as the show. Not only that, but we won't strictly be picking people from this stretch of post-AS seasons, we'll take people from any SI season up to that point. The focus would likely be on newer players, but there will most definitely be some 'old school' players asked back as well

ANYWAY! This thread will be for anyone to share their opinions on who from this season should be asked back for a future season. Whether it's AS, HvV, second chances, etc. All Star titles are always fun and challenging to come up with, so feel free to throw out suggestions for those as well

Since the players from this season won't know 100% if they'll be asked back for an AS season, all they'll have to go by are the comments in this thread. If they're on a lot of lists and talked about a lot, they'll have a pretty good idea that they'll be asked back

DISCUSS! Who deserves to be brought back in the future?

Laura

All Stars: Jamie, Leann, Chet, Hatch, Ciera (based off people that were dynamic players. John was excluded because having the F3 all back would be kind of lame).

Favorites (assuming they are actual favorites and not whatever s4 were): John, LeAnn, Dreamz, Dave, Greg

Second Chance: Peih Gee, Kathy -- Nick

If you're going by the series as a whole and not just this stretch of seasons, then I think the only people that stand out enough would be Jamie and Ciera. If you were just doing this stretch than I don't think that'd be the base!

For a FvF season I would say Leann, Todd, John and Hatch.

Second chances has to be Peih-Gee, Kathy and Gillian!

Oh I forgot Dave and Dreamz for FvF as well!

Just a list of people who I'd like to see again for AS, second chances, FvF, anything really:

Jamie
John
Kelly
Todd
Dreamz
Ciera
Hatch
Greg
Peih-Gee
Nick

I find your lack of Cathy distrurbing.

Jamie
John
Leann
Dave
Hatch
Ciera
Greg
Kathy
Dr. Sean

Big flashy players: Jamie Ciera
Favorite themed season: John Leann
Second Chance: Greg, Peih-Gee, Nick, maybe Kathy

You guys don't have to split the players into certain themed games, since we don't really know what we'll be trying out. It might be better to tier by WHY you think they deserve a return, rather than the exact season.

Top tier:

Jamie - nothing really needs to be said, but he was the star this season and also polarizing especially now.

Leanne - entertaining and intellectual. She was a great addition this season and I think she was one of the more well rounded players this season.

Ciera: nothing about her game was good and she was in no way a threat, but she was one of the most, if not, the most polarizing person in this season. It's like the Abi of Sausage. Just so either you hate her or love her; nothing in between and strictly based on personality.

Middle tier:

John - played very under the radar, but still made a huge impact on the sseason . He just wasn't as out there and apparent as Jamie.

Chet - I think he would play much better his second time around. He was a consistent player, just not the best strategically but most aren't anyways. I thought he was entertaining and great in challenges.

Dreamz - My boy Dreamz!! I thought he would be so polarizing but he ended up being a root able underdog which is funny. If he was dealt a different hand, I think things would have been a lot different. He is another well rounded player.

Dave - Entertaining and was one of the few willing to make a move. He got caught making a move late. I think he was one of the other well rounded players.

Hatch - similar to Ciara but more game smart. Too polarizing not to have back.

Low tier:

Kelly - I just didn't see as much from her as I would have hoped. She should have at least tried something but just followed and did what she was told in order to get 4th place.

Todd - pretty much the same as Kelly.

Any returner season:

Greg, PG, Cathy, Nick

Sarge

I have way too many people on my list but I couldn't cut it down.

Jamie - He controlled this season and deserves his place in the end. He did great as alias with a secret F2. I'd love to see him play where the other players already know his game.

Leann - Top notch player, a little quirky and weird. (Would fit in so well in Portland.) She didn't realize her own power in the game or what she could have accomplished so I'd love to see what she would do with a second chance (or is it third cause she said something about going from 11th place to 3rd in her confessional?). Either way, she should come back.

John - He's a chill guy, very likable, not necessarily in the forefront but he had his moments. Staying over Yau Man was huge! Definitely deserves to come back.

Chet - He really stepped his game-play up near the end and probably could've made the finals if there was a F3 and not a F2 this season.

Dreamz - He really did become so rootable in the game and not just for entertainment value but because he never gave up, always tried to make something happen. He surprised me in his game-play and provided many many laughs this season.

Greg - I never watched/read his previous season through so I'm not that familiar with how he played before except that he was a sheister I guess? THIS season, he was pretty fun to watch, though. He had a hilarious but impossible strategy and still did pretty well. He is overall just so entertaining to watch. You just wonder what that brain will think of next.

Kelly - I love Kelly. Very smart player, UTR but made it far. I was always hoping she'd do a little more but I'd love to see her play again.

Todd - He has a lot of potential and could've done a lot more if he didn't trust Jamie so much...but then that was half the cast. I'd like to see him come back.

Hatch - I loved watching him in the game. He never sat still, never stopped trying to save himself.

Ciera - Definitely polaring. Probably the most talked about player of the season besides Jamie.

Dave - Love this guy! He needs to come back! His mackin days are far from over!!

Peigh-Gee - Had some bad breaks and left too early but I think she could've made it to the end if one or two things had been different for her.

Kathy - I wanted to see so much more of Kathy. Gone way too soon and definitely needs to come back!

Nick - He had so much potential and definitely deserves to come back.

Danni - I liked watching her cause of the drama - I wanted the Ciera blindside so badly! I was loving Gwad before the tribes switched, partially because of Danni.





HvV PLEASE!!!

Shawna Vs. Reynold

Reynold @ 27/2/2014 12:38

Shawna Vs. Reynold

We both wear masks...(Shawna's tba). RI: Shawna Vs Reynold with all the rest new players. We have a winner.