Timmah @ 10/8/2015 22:58

You just claimed to have performed 2 kills AND 1 unconfirmed roleblock. That just doesn't make sense to me. But, by all means, lynch me and lose it for the town (or maybe get closer to winning if for yourself)

In a sense, you have a point but the two kills working completely different and the fact that we seem to lack a normal vigilante makes me think this is a slightly modified JOAT to fit the premise of a smaller game.

1 slow kill. 1 normal kill. 1 roleblock.

We know that town has none of those abilities. Makes sense to me if you compare it to all the other town roles in the game.

Reading back through the last day phase now. I must've been drinking too much Saturday (read: I assuredly was) because I missed, or maybe I just forgot, that entire interplay between Red and Herm

Timmah

Brian being RB'd could help that argument, but there are alternatives to that too, one of which you have mentioned yourself (though, I'm not sure why you'd do that if you were mafia)

My thinking is that there's only 2 scum left, both of them being mafia. Mafia Roleblocker and Mafia Redirector.

Timmah @ 10/8/2015 23:09

Reading back through the last day phase now. I must've been drinking too much Saturday (read: I assuredly was) because I missed, or maybe I just forgot, that entire interplay between Red and Herm

It was quite the session lol.

sorry, what's the reasoning behind thinking there's a redirecter?

itsbrianyay @ 10/8/2015 15:26

sorry, what's the reasoning behind thinking there's a redirecter?

I was wondering that as well.

Herm @ 10/8/2015 15:05

In a sense, you have a point but the two kills working completely different and the fact that we seem to lack a normal vigilante makes me think this is a slightly modified JOAT to fit the premise of a smaller game. 1 slow kill. 1 normal kill. 1 roleblock. We know that town has none of those abilities. Makes sense to me if you compare it to all the other town roles in the game.

Yep, and I has other things too!

The fact that Brian got roleblocked instead of me, my theory was that I got switched with Brian. Although I guess it's probably more likely that I didn't get told about it since I don't have a visiting role like Brian and Buffy. Plus, only one person seems to have been blocked.

why couldn't they have just blocked me twice in a row?

i think having a bus driver and redirector in such a small game is unlikely since conflicting power usages could get weird.

Yeah, I think what you guys say makes more sense. I couldn't explain at first why I wasn't notified, but it's obviously because I don't have visiting rights.

Hi I haven't caught up but do you want me to claim?

Curtis @ 10/8/2015 16:01

Hi I haven't caught up but do you want me to claim?

yes

Curtis @ 10/8/2015 16:01

Hi I haven't caught up but do you want me to claim?

We all have

Herm = VT
Timmah = VT
Redster = JoaT
Brian = ??
Rose = ??
Curtis = ??

I think Brian is Friendly Neighbor.

Herm @ 10/8/2015 16:05

I think Brian is Friendly Neighbor.

I'm not a fan of making other people's claims for them. Was wanting him to say it a little more clearly, but yes it does look like that was implied.