Herm @ 10/8/2015 14:54

I don't think the vig was blocked. We have only seen 1 individual get blocked for each phase. As for the vig potentially being a SK. I don't think so. There was only one kill night 1 and while there is an argument to be made about SK and mafia killing the same person, if we had a SK instead of a vig then I feel that town would be slightly underpowered.

That's not true. Remember Lamps was injured/infected/poisoned/something on N1 and died on D2

Hm, you have a point. I assumed the two kills came from the same source, but thinking about it that doesn't make sense.

The first killer used his/her ability on night 1. The other killed seems to have only killed once, on night 2, as far as we are aware.

Herm @ 10/8/2015 11:33

Brian's not necessarily a known, but there are a few circumstances that more or less makes him almost confirmed town. 1. Someone blocked Buffy night 1, Brian has since then been blocked both nights 2 and 3. 2. IM317, who flipped as mafia goon, claimed roleblocker and no one counter claimed. There has also only been one roleblock per night. 3. Brian feels like an odd target to block for two consecutive nights in a row, if the roleblocker is town.

Why would a town roleblocker bother counter claiming? It was pretty clear that im317 was gonna be lynch regardless.

Fact:

Either Timmah, Curtis, or Rose killed Buffy

what makes you say that?

itsbrianyay @ 10/8/2015 13:27

what makes you say that?

Reasons

there's 6 people alive, i feel like reasons need to be discussed at this point

Well, if the individual who killed Lamps is not town which is plausible since he/she attacked someone Night 1, then this person could very well be some sort of SK. I don't think he/she's aligned with the mafia however.

Wikey fake claimed to be responsible for killing Lamps Day 2, this seems to have caught mafia's attention as Wikey was killed the following night, along with mafia GF Ari. I think we can figure out who this is, I didn't want to do it yesterday as I thought this individual could be the vigilante. Either way, we're all claiming today so we're gonna bring stuff out into the surface anyway. Since Wikey was tracker, my theory yesterday was that he tracked someone night 1, the same person who attacked Lamps.

This doesn't necessarily have to be the case, but it is a theory I based on the fact he fake claimed that thing in the first place lol. Whoever it was, it could've been someone Wikey thought was town on Day 2.

Redster, are you open to claiming first?

Prediction: I think Rose is the person who killed Lamps. Wikey probably figured she was town which is an explanation to why he found Buffy more suspicious.

Herm @ 10/8/2015 13:39

Redster, are you open to claiming first?

I would rather have scum claim first.

That being said, I could very well be wrong about this killer's identity so.... mass claim time?

Herm @ 10/8/2015 13:49

That being said, I could very well be wrong about this killer's identity so.... mass claim time?

Why you in such a hurry? You seem to be pushing this pretty hard today? We still have a couple people yet to check in...

Redster @ 10/8/2015 21:47

Herm @ 10/8/2015 13:39 Redster, are you open to claiming first? I would rather have scum claim first.

So in your opinion, Timmah, Curtis or Rose?

Well, as long as we claim, I'm all for it. I didn't want to start initially, but I have no problems claiming first just so we can get the ball rolling lol.

Redster @ 10/8/2015 21:52

Herm @ 10/8/2015 13:49 That being said, I could very well be wrong about this killer's identity so.... mass claim time? Why you in such a hurry? You seem to be pushing this pretty hard today? We still have a couple people yet to check in...

I was adamant about claiming yesterday, but we eventually agreed to do it, more or less. We never got around to it and we just waited and waited,,, until we decided to do it today. There's no guarantee that Rose will show up and everyone else has already checked in.

You don't seem to want to wanna claim at all lol. I'll get the ball rolling soon, just saying. Then we'll claim one after the other.