The theory is still dumb and baseless, though. Causation vs. correlation says so

I'm waiting for the "primate always offers himself as a lynch when he's scum" meta to get going, even though I did it as town in the last game.

Penner @ 11/2/2020 5:40

Also knowing he’s like 40 makes his shtick less appealing. I’d expect that from someone no older than like 22

So bitter

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:52

The theory is still dumb and baseless, though. Causation vs. correlation says so

In conclusion, primate is dumb and baseless?

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:51

Timmah @ 11/2/2020 9:59 Thanks for the game TIB! I should've realized that in a TIB game everyone is going to be scum and just self-protected every night. Instead I saved spin and died. Worst decision ever! I did cast 4 votes, for 4 scums. Not that impressive I guess when everyone is scum. Primate slipped on day 2 by saying there were 2 scum factions, thus continuing the theory that the first person to mention something like this is in one of them. That's a dumb theory. I do it all the time as town. I normally wouldn't do it as scum because of that stupid reoccuring theory. I thought it was mentioned D1, but was mistaken, so it was a slip in that I normally wouldn't do it as scum.

It is a slip and you thought it had been mentioned because it probably had been, in your scum forum. That's why it's a solid theory. There was no reason to think there'd be 2 scum teams at that point in the game, unless you had extra information and had discussed that in your scum forum. Great theory imo.

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:57

Penner @ 11/2/2020 5:40 Also knowing he’s like 40 makes his shtick less appealing. I’d expect that from someone no older than like 22 So bitter

Who is this referring to? Primate is pushing 70

It's Wednesday @ 11/2/2020 12:20

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:52 The theory is still dumb and baseless, though. Causation vs. correlation says so In conclusion, primate is dumb and baseless?

Yes

Timmah @ 11/2/2020 13:28

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:51 Timmah @ 11/2/2020 9:59 Thanks for the game TIB! I should've realized that in a TIB game everyone is going to be scum and just self-protected every night. Instead I saved spin and died. Worst decision ever! I did cast 4 votes, for 4 scums. Not that impressive I guess when everyone is scum. Primate slipped on day 2 by saying there were 2 scum factions, thus continuing the theory that the first person to mention something like this is in one of them. That's a dumb theory. I do it all the time as town. I normally wouldn't do it as scum because of that stupid reoccuring theory. I thought it was mentioned D1, but was mistaken, so it was a slip in that I normally wouldn't do it as scum. It is a slip and you thought it had been mentioned because it probably had been, in your scum forum. That's why it's a solid theory. There was no reason to think there'd be 2 scum teams at that point in the game, unless you had extra information and had discussed that in your scum forum. Great theory imo.

It's a tib game. I would have brought it up as scum. Just like I'm always paranoid that there's a cult in a buffy game.

Rodney @ 11/2/2020 13:40

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:57 Penner @ 11/2/2020 5:40 Also knowing he’s like 40 makes his shtick less appealing. I’d expect that from someone no older than like 22 So bitter Who is this referring to? Primate is pushing 70

That's hurtful, Penner.

Timmah @ 11/2/2020 13:28

Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:51 Timmah @ 11/2/2020 9:59 Thanks for the game TIB! I should've realized that in a TIB game everyone is going to be scum and just self-protected every night. Instead I saved spin and died. Worst decision ever! I did cast 4 votes, for 4 scums. Not that impressive I guess when everyone is scum. Primate slipped on day 2 by saying there were 2 scum factions, thus continuing the theory that the first person to mention something like this is in one of them. That's a dumb theory. I do it all the time as town. I normally wouldn't do it as scum because of that stupid reoccuring theory. I thought it was mentioned D1, but was mistaken, so it was a slip in that I normally wouldn't do it as scum. It is a slip and you thought it had been mentioned because it probably had been, in your scum forum. That's why it's a solid theory. There was no reason to think there'd be 2 scum teams at that point in the game, unless you had extra information and had discussed that in your scum forum. Great theory imo.

It's the tail wagging the dog, but that's mafia. You form a dumbass theory, then convince yourself it's right.

Primate @ 11/2/2020 16:38

Rodney @ 11/2/2020 13:40 Primate @ 11/2/2020 12:57 Penner @ 11/2/2020 5:40 Also knowing he’s like 40 makes his shtick less appealing. I’d expect that from someone no older than like 22 So bitter Who is this referring to? Primate is pushing 70 That's hurtful, Penner.

I’m not talking about you, small-brain

I have an update.

I'm over it. lol

Herm @ 10/2/2020 22:51

Great game TIB!

Wow........

i won

wheres the other mafia forum