I think we were winning anyway

Rod Six @ 28/4/2019 2:45

Thanks so much herm you were amazing. I was getting so into the flavor. Please host again you killed it

Thanks Rodney! I'll have someone help balance the roles/setup if I decide to host again. I'll think about it.

I did enjoy writing flavor though, so glad you enjoyed it lol.

Wait, who was actually alive after all the night actions resolved? Didnt SK Zersch kill Mafia Ahoda?

SK Zersch killed Ahoda, but Primate protected him.

Shadow killed Mads, who was left unprotected during the night, because she couldn't protect back to back.

As long as there was a non-mafia killer out there, the game should have continued. There would have been one Cult (im317) and one SK still in the game.

Sure, the mafia would have had a voting advantage, but they hadn't eliminated all threats yet.

Win condition didn't say eliminate threats

Rod Six @ 28/4/2019 2:49

I think we were winning anyway

Town, and SK/Cult had town reads on you, Shadow and Primate throughout the majority of the game.

The only times Mafia was targeted at all was Cody jailing Christian on N1, Spin attacked Christian N2 (but he was protected) and Zersch attacked Ahoda N4 (but he was protected). Town mostly just targeted each other, while Mafia/SK/Cult helped out from the sidelines.

If the Town roles had targeted Mafia with all their PR roles, then Mafia could've just easily been dealt a heavy blow early lol. You managed to get as far as you did because most people never targeted you.

Mafia knew who SK was and would have voted him out. IM was obvious cult recruiter and we would have blocked him.


Thanks for hosting Herm


Out of curiosity, what mistakes did you make?

Mafia sending IM to havo and then ya railroading havo with the Locke’s vote count was my favorite part. The trolling is always my favorite part

Qui-Gon Spin @ 27/4/2019 19:53

As long as there was a non-mafia killer out there, the game should have continued. There would have been one Cult (im317) and one SK still in the game. Sure, the mafia would have had a voting advantage, but they hadn't eliminated all threats yet.

I had two votes ; whate this "advantage"? (:

I cant see the forums; they all say no threads

Town Win Condition: You win when all threats to the Town have been eliminated.
- They had to remove the Serial Killers, Mafia and Cult to win the game. They needed SK, Cult and Mafia to wipe out each other during nights.

Cult Win Condition: You win when all threats to the Cult has been eliminated and you are on par with the same numbers as Town.
- They needed to wipe out Mafia and SK, and would win automatically if it was just them and Town left.

Mafia Win Condition: You win when your faction secures half the numbers in play.
- When their team consisted of 50% of the remaining players, they posed the greatest threat to all the other players.

SK Win Condition: You win when all threats to you have been eliminated and you are on par with the same numbers as Town.
- They needed to erase Mafia and Cult to win.

It was a bit of a clusterfuck in the end.

Helios Garabandia @ 28/4/2019 3:02

I cant see the forums; they all say no threads

Oh. Maybe I put them on invisible. Hang on.

Are the forums open now?

thanks Herm. Good job team!