DS @ 5/11/2017 20:57

Dwayne JohnSeb @ 5/11/2017 21:56 Assuming that the setup was what you thought it was and not being open to other possibilities + lynching someone who you thought was town to "clear" him is what did Town in. I didnt think Zach was town. I thought it was either Zach or Curtis. I did not think that Tim was 3p I thought he was just stupid town.

I can agree with you on the latter part at least.

Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:56

DS @ 5/11/2017 23:55 Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:54 DS @ 5/11/2017 23:52 With 4 v 1 v 1 we had to play it perfectly for town to win and the no lynch on D2 did us in Lynching Zach instead of Seb did you in. You forced me to go after Zach instead of Seb or get lynched myself. If we had lynched Seb I'd have met my win condition and refocused on going after the killer. There is no way for us to have known you were 3p. You literally could have just told us that lmfao there was no way we were voting you first with a killer out there You voted me. I was only not lynched because I had to switch to Zach.

Literally had to do that to get you to switch off your vote otherwise it was going to end in a no lynch again

DS @ 5/11/2017 23:58

Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:56 DS @ 5/11/2017 23:55 Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:54 DS @ 5/11/2017 23:52 With 4 v 1 v 1 we had to play it perfectly for town to win and the no lynch on D2 did us in Lynching Zach instead of Seb did you in. You forced me to go after Zach instead of Seb or get lynched myself. If we had lynched Seb I'd have met my win condition and refocused on going after the killer. There is no way for us to have known you were 3p. You literally could have just told us that lmfao there was no way we were voting you first with a killer out there You voted me. I was only not lynched because I had to switch to Zach. Literally had to do that to get you to switch off your vote otherwise it was going to end in a no lynch again

Which would have been better for your odds of getting the killer lmao. your whole reason for not lynching rested entirely on Curtis's words about how easy it would be to know who the killer was with him using his protection on someone.

No lynching was definitely the way to go with this game's setup until you knew for sure who the killer was.

Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:59

DS @ 5/11/2017 23:58 Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:56 DS @ 5/11/2017 23:55 Tim @ 5/11/2017 21:54 DS @ 5/11/2017 23:52 With 4 v 1 v 1 we had to play it perfectly for town to win and the no lynch on D2 did us in Lynching Zach instead of Seb did you in. You forced me to go after Zach instead of Seb or get lynched myself. If we had lynched Seb I'd have met my win condition and refocused on going after the killer. There is no way for us to have known you were 3p. You literally could have just told us that lmfao there was no way we were voting you first with a killer out there You voted me. I was only not lynched because I had to switch to Zach. Literally had to do that to get you to switch off your vote otherwise it was going to end in a no lynch again Which would have been better for your odds of getting the killer lmao. your whole reason for not lynching rested entirely on Curtis's words about how easy it would be to know who the killer was with him using his protection on someone.

No, I was pushing a lynch from D2, its how you play small setups like this. You nl d1 to narrow the candidates then lynch day 2 when you still have a mislynch and then the killer either no kills to get it down to 2 v 2 if they think they cant win a 2 v 1.

You guys need to spend some time on epic mafia to learn strategies

The 3p role definitely threw that all out the window though, great twist Jamie

Lynching people unless you're absolutely sure they're scum is dumb with such a small group. One town lynch could destroy your whole chances of winning lol.

The only reason I was lynch voting was to target Seb

Like lynching the Doc on Day 1.

Tim @ 5/11/2017 22:04

Lynching people unless you're absolutely sure they're scum is dumb with such a small group. One town lynch could destroy your whole chances of winning lol.

Nah, without the presence of you as third party we had a mislynch available to us. 2 v 1 is where you want to be at endgame as town

GG guys, Thanks Jamie!

Since we all had a win condition to guess the room, weapon and person it is absolutely not worth it to lynch people during the day. Keep as many people alive and investigating as possible and we could all get a win.

It was 2 v 1 alright.

People here are way too obsessed with having someone lynched every day.

I can't enjoy the fact that I won because of all the arguing with DS :(

Dude no one is arguing with you, you’re arguing with yourself. Enjoy it.