Day One
Ruby Slippers - randomized to Mafia Goon/Mittens
Traitor/Vic - Not on town lynch 0/4 (started GF lynch)

Night One
Mafia JOAT/Dadd - Puppet Curtis to kill Maddie
Mafia Fireball/Patrick - n/a
Mafia Roleblocker/Farlig - Blocks Ascetic/Bryce
Mafia Doctor/Brian - Protect Cal-Pro
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Search Badger for Traitor

Third Party Cult Leader/Herm - Recruits Town Vanilla/Christian

Town Inventor/Zach - Gives forum meet-up to Town Backup/Maddie
Town Protector/Merc - Protects self
Town Watcher/Timmah - Watches Mafia JOAT/Dadd
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hides behind Even Day Vig/Sock
Town Tracker/Lamps - Tracks Ascetic/Bryce (n/a Bryce blocked)
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigates Town Backup/Maddie (n/a Maddie dies)
Town Odd Night Vig/Jamie - Kills Mayor/Spin
Town Vote Stealer/Primate - Steals Doc/Merc's vote
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Blocks actions (sans kills) used on Traitor/Vic (blocked)
Town Roleblocker/Curtis - Blocks Town Vanilla/Christian (n/a)
Town Bookie/Angi - Bets on Town RB/Curtis as D2 lynch
Town Carriage Driver/Nofo - Bus Vlady and Curtis (action was late)
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to Maddie: Me and my goth van are town! Let me know how I can help you.


Day Two
Town Even Day Vig/Sock - Kills Town Doc/Merc
Town Vote Stealer/Primate - Uses extra vote on Merc
Town Bookie Angi - If Curtis is lynched, gets a kill N2 - didn't happen
Ding Dong - Timmah - can submit any message to be posted upon opening of D3

Night Two
Mafia JOAT/Dadd - Frame Curtis as scum (bussed to Sock)
Mafia Fireball/Patrick - Search Christian for traitor (not traitor)
Mafia Roleblocker/Farlig - Block Ben
Mafia Doctor/Brian - Kill Lamps
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Use Ruby Slippers to commute

Third Party Cult Leader/Herm - Recruit Fireball/Patrick (Fails, Patrick is dead already due to Timmah visit)

Town Inventor/Zach - Give out Doorman/block to Josh
Town Watcher/Timmah - Watch Patrick (Triggers fireball which kills both Timmah/Patrick)
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hides behind TIB/Town Vanilla
Town Tracker/Lamps - Tracks Zach (Fails, Lamps is dead)
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Did not submit
Town Vote Stealer/Primate - Did not submit
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Blocks actions (sans kills) used on Zach
Town Roleblocker/Curtis - Blocks Vlady
Town Bookie/Angi - Bets on Zach for lynch
Town Carriage Driver/Nofo - Bus Curtis and Sock
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message Primate right now( watch him be scum): "Me and my goth van are town. I feel you are the same. How can I help?" (Blocked by Curtis)


Day Three
Town Bookie Angi - If Zach is lynched, gets a kill N2 - didn't happen
TIB receives charred Straw Hat (no effect)

Night Three
Mafia JOAT/Dadd - Track Bryce (Blocked, plus Dadd killed)
Mafia Roleblocker/Farlig - Block Badger (n/a)
Mafia Doctor/Brian - Kill Jamie
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Search Bryce (not traitor)

Third Party Cult Leader/Herm - Recruit Curtis (success)

Town Inventor/Zach - Give Meet-up forum to Jamie (n/a Jamie dead)
Town Odd Night Vig/Jamie - Kill Dadd
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hides behind Curtis (resolved before recruitment, Ahoda lives)
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigates Josh (town)
Town Vote Stealer/Primate - Steal Farlig's vote
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Blocks actions (sans kills) used on im317 (n/a)
Town Roleblocker/Curtis - Blocks Angi (bet does not go through)
Town Bookie/Angi - Bets on Herm as D4 Lynch (n/a, blocked)
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to: Badger: "Me and my goth van are town. I feel you are the same. How can I help?"
Town Day Extender/Josh - Blocks Dadd (with block from Zach)

Day Four
Town Even Day Vig/Sock - Kills Town Bookie/Angi
Town Day Extender/Josh - Extends deadline one hour
Town Innocent Child/im317 - Activates role, mod-confirmed as town
Town BP/Badger response to Vlady: "Im TownBP. Tell Ahoda he can hide behind me safely" (delivered after day 4 ends)

Night Four
Mafia Roleblocker/Farlig - Kill Curtis (blocked)
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Search Herm (not traitor)

Third Party Cult Leader/Herm - Recruit Primate (successful)
Cult Roleblocker/Curtis - Block Farlig (stops kill)

Town Inventor/Zach - Give Gun/Day Kill to Town Vanilla/TIB (successful)
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hide behind Bryce (successful)
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigate Bryce (receives info - Bryce is town)
Town Vote Stealer/Primate - Steal Mittens vote (successful)
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Block actions (sans kills) used on Ahoda (n/a)
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to: Curtis - "My goth van is town. Badger claims Town BP. Need help?" (successfully delivered)

Day Five
TIB daykills Herm - Herm (survives kill because BP)
Cult RB/Curtis response to Vlady: RBlocked farlig n4. Hes mafia. U lead charge tmrw (delivered after day 5 ends)

Night Five
Mafia Roleblocker/Farlig - Search Cal-Pro for missing member
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Kill Sock

Third Party Cult Follower Leader/Ben - Recruit Badger
Cult Roleblocker/Curtis - Block Cal-Pro
Cult Vote Stealer/Primate - Steal im317's vote

Town Inventor/Zach - Give Track to Badger [Balloon Ride (Track) - May give a night balloon ride out, this person will have a great vantage point and be able to track the person of their choice.]
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hide behind Cal-Pro
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigate Farlig (blocked)
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Block actions (sans kills) used on Vic (n/a)
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to: Bryce - "Goth van = town. farlig rbed last night = no kill = mafia"

Day Six
Town Ascetic/Bryce response to Vlady: I will make sure your night actions go through. Keep it up. (delivered after day 6 ends)

Night Six
Mafia Goon/Mittens - Search Ben to find out if he is missing mafia member (blocked by Curtis)

Third Party Cult Follower Leader/Ben - Recruit Zach
Cult Roleblocker/Curtis - Block Mittens
Cult Vote Stealer/Primate - Steal Josh's vote
Cult BP/Badger - Track Vic

Town Inventor/Zach - Give forum visit to Bryce
Town Hider/Ahoda - Hide behind Vic (dies)
Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigate Mittens (non-town)
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Block actions (sans kills) used on Vlady
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to: TIB - "Goth van here. Curt=RB, Badger=BP. How can I help?"


Day Seven
TIB response to Vlady - Buffy loves me. Except she gave me nothing as a role. (delivered after Day 7 ends)
Mittens dies, Ruby Slippers to Cal (last person on lynch) - n/a

Night Seven
Third Party Cult Follower Leader/Ben - Recruit Vlady (success, cult wins)
Cult Roleblocker/Curtis - Block Josh, receives Protection from Zach (n/a)
Cult Vote Stealer/Primate - Steal Vic's vote (n/a)
Cult Inventor/Zach - Give Protection to Curtis

Town Cop/Cal-Pro - Investigate Curtis - (n/a, game over)
Town Ascetic/Bryce - Block actions (sans kills) used on Zach - (n/a, plus game over)
Town Whisperer/Vlady - Message to: Curtis - "TIB=no role. Bryce ensures role works. Plz no b cult. :("

Note Night Four - Farlig tries to kill Curtis but Curtis blocks it and saves himself. Good choice by Curtis lol.

These sons of bitches non stop framing me

Curtis @ 14/9/2017 0:54

These sons of bitches non stop framing me

I don't know why they didn't puppet someone to kill you. (I would've lol)

One suggestion to fix the cult being OP thing:

Limit the number of members they can have at any one time. If you had limited Cult to, say, a max of 4 members, it would have worked a bit better, from a balanced point of view. Once they get to 4, they can't recruit again until one is killed.

Town could also potentially lynch cult at any point before the end of the game. Or mafia could target cult.

Ugh Vlady giving out role info helps cult

spindoctor02 @ 14/9/2017 1:06

One suggestion to fix the cult being OP thing: Limit the number of members they can have at any one time. If you had limited Cult to, say, a max of 4 members, it would have worked a bit better, from a balanced point of view. Once they get to 4, they can't recruit again until one is killed. Town could also potentially lynch cult at any point before the end of the game. Or mafia could target cult.

Thanks I will take that under advisement, BFF. Seriously, though, I like the idea of forcing Cult to make a kill. I was hungrrrrry for a cult kill lol.

Limited recruits, plus kills or something maybe.

Herminator @ 14/9/2017 1:44

Limited recruits, plus kills or something maybe.

I like all these suggestions. You guys were kind of my guinea pigs and I tried reallly hard to make it fair. I adjusted things with both Mafia and Town to keep them powerful. Mafia kind of got unlucky and so did town with all the early PR kills.

Bryce @ 14/9/2017 1:08

Ugh Vlady giving out role info helps cult

Sure did, he told me Tom's role which is why we recruited him

Bryce @ 14/9/2017 0:08

Ugh Vlady giving out role info helps cult

At that point, cult hadn't flipped. As I said in our side board, I was trying to be the PF for the town council that didn't exist.

I thought about the riskiness of it, but thought it was balanced by the potential benefit.

My last message to curtis even said "Plz no b cult".

For cult, as I said in the other thread, I tend to limit the recruiter/backup so that they die if they recruit the unrecruitable. I also don't tend to make them bullet proof.

My most limited cult "recruiter" was Cthulhu, who recruited anyone who visited him automatically, regardless of alignment. "Visit" didn't include watchers and stuff like that. When a mafia person got "recruited", the rest of the mafia board knew that the player was no longer with them and what they were going to do, so it outted Cthulhu to them. Then they had to decide what to do with the info.

Throw in a second cult and the possibility of double crosses

Great work cult, I'm glad you won :)