So, I thought there were a lot of good moves and things that were very entertaining. I didn't really do a lot of HOL's because ... I just loved a lot of things I guess! Anyway, I may have forgotten someone/something so if so don't take it personally. This is what I could recall...


HOF:

Wikey - He really came alive and began scum-hunting on Day 5. Day 6 made that amazing chart, which I'd give him HOF for alone lol. He also seemed to be the only one to really be skeptical of Helios even after the Cop soft-claim. Other than Zersch, of course, who knew he was scum when Curtis tried to recruit Helios and died.

Mittens - He missed D1 and D2 completely so HOL for that... but when he arrived on D3 he did a great job going forward, both in the day threads and for Mafia. He was one of the main strategic minds and also at times was the voice of reason in that group, although advocating against killing Primate may have bitten him in the ass since Primate lynched him with the help of Zersch's info.

Helios - Throwing Jamie under the bus really gained him town credit. His role claim was also great since no one else could've countered-claimed... although I think the fact that there was nothing about "scanning town" in Maddie or Curtis's roles should've clued people in earlier that there probably wasn't a cop. I guess people are just used to cops.

Sock and Zersch - just for making me laugh so much.

Sock - His scum reads were pretty good. D5 he had Helios, Lamps and Mittens all on his list as scum. He hung back and people kept thinking he was scummy, but it allowed him to stay alive and keep trying to save town with his role. He was on DS the night he was killed but the kill was unstoppable and his kill was only 50/50 - and it did fail.

Cult team (Curtis/Zersch) + Primate - for the use of the bullhorn and ballpoint pen together - Zersch sending a note to Primate letting him know #1 he's Tracker and #2 Mittens is scum and killed Merc; then Primate's idea to get Curtis to use the bullhorn and Curtis's agreement knowing who Primate would likely lynch.

Jamie - He was very active and on top of things for Mafia before his death. Also, even though he did come close to crossing the line a couple of times :P I was glad he was enjoying the game and his flavor talk was fun for me since most people in the game didn't know the show.

The Cult team in general (Curtis/Herm/Zersch) - for making the board so fun with their thematic posts and thinking through recruits so thoroughly. Merc would've been a great choice and was such a weird Mafia target that night when Mafia could've killed/blocked Primate and Dylan. :P That choice did end up really hurting cult, though, since Merc wasn't recruited and Primate was left alive to kill Herm.

Curtis - For recruiting Zersch. That was a really good choice and one which wasn't obvious since Zersch hadn't claimed when Curtis would've been able to recruit. It was just those good VIBES!

Brian - For constantly being seen as scummy but staying alive and getting his voting power up to the maximum of 3. He did come close to being lynched the day Jamie was lynched. If Helios would've switched last minute, Brian would've been gone. And obviously for keeping his role alive so he was really going to be the sole lynching power unless the other people lynched him first, but they gave him the leeway.

Primate - For the Vic kill. That was out of the blue but obviously a good choice. Also the Herm kill, I guess.. lol. JK that really hurt cult and helped town. Also, for taking Zersch's info and asking Curtis to use the bullhorn and advocating to be elected. Such a take charge day for him.

DS - For saving town N1 even though it was pretty much a gamble with how lame D1 was.

Christian, Wikey and late game Dylan- For PMing their game thoughts to me. I always like reading those.


HOL:

Rose - I don't think I need to elaborate lol...

Primate - Killing Angi N1 with very little info to go on from the lethargic D1 thread. Scum Angi is usually pretty easy to spot if you give her a day or 2 so that was unnecessary imo. Also I'm not a big fan of a vig shooting blindly on N1 since you're so much more likely to hit town but, if you're trigger-happy like Primate :P why not just kill an inactive like scumMittens who hadn't even shown up on D1. He would've hit mafia.

Inactivity/vacations :P

Cult - Recruiting Helios, although that's being nit-picky. He was soft-claiming cop and threw all of his teammates under the bus so he did look very town. It's only lame because I was having fun watching the cult and poor Zersch had to take over the cult wing when he didn't even start the cult! I was really hoping for a Wikey or Brian recruit that night. Wikey would've been fun to watch on the cult board and of course he wouldn't have been on Curtis's back as much. Brian would've also been fun AND he had his really powerful role which would've probably helped ensure a cult victory.

Vlady - For shooting the gun so early and at all lol. I guess some people will always shoot a gun but there's obviously a danger as we've seen a few times. Also, even if the gun had worked he would've shot town. I don't think DS had claimed by that point but Vlady had until the next evening to make his decision.

Farlig - For not even trying to fight his lynch. To be fair, I don't think he was around at the end of the day but he had a couple of votes on him early in the day when he was still around and never advocated as to why he wasn't a good lynch.

Christian - For outing im317 so soon lol.

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:17

So, I thought there were a lot of good moves and things that were very entertaining. I didn't really do a lot of HOL's because ... I just loved a lot of things I guess! Anyway, I may have forgotten someone/something so if so don't take it personally. This is what I could recall...

Yeah, I don't remember my game either.

Thanks for running the game Buffy! Sorry for the relative inactivity.

spindoctor02 @ 29/3/2017 23:22

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:17 So, I thought there were a lot of good moves and things that were very entertaining. I didn't really do a lot of HOL's because ... I just loved a lot of things I guess! Anyway, I may have forgotten someone/something so if so don't take it personally. This is what I could recall... Yeah, I don't remember my game either. Thanks for running the game Buffy! Sorry for the relative inactivity.

lol sorry Spin. You did GREAT at not being recruited. :P

And yw!

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:26

spindoctor02 @ 29/3/2017 23:22 Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:17 So, I thought there were a lot of good moves and things that were very entertaining. I didn't really do a lot of HOL's because ... I just loved a lot of things I guess! Anyway, I may have forgotten someone/something so if so don't take it personally. This is what I could recall... Yeah, I don't remember my game either. Thanks for running the game Buffy! Sorry for the relative inactivity. lol sorry Spin. You did GREAT at not being recruited. :P And yw!

Also great at not being targeted. I think I was targeted twice all game, once when Primate tried to kill me, and then when Zersch was out of people to track.

Thanks for hosting Buff!

spindoctor02 @ 29/3/2017 22:27

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:26 spindoctor02 @ 29/3/2017 23:22 Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:17 So, I thought there were a lot of good moves and things that were very entertaining. I didn't really do a lot of HOL's because ... I just loved a lot of things I guess! Anyway, I may have forgotten someone/something so if so don't take it personally. This is what I could recall... Yeah, I don't remember my game either. Thanks for running the game Buffy! Sorry for the relative inactivity. lol sorry Spin. You did GREAT at not being recruited. :P And yw! Also great at not being targeted. I think I was targeted twice all game, once when Primate tried to kill me, and then when Zersch was out of people to track.

I seen't you doing... things. But the specifics died with me.

this is my first solo appearance on a HOF ty

Glad Primate got HOL :P

Belated/special added HOL - Maddie's Really Old Guy claim and supposed mod-kill lol

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:24

Belated/special added HOL - Maddie's Really Old Guy claim and supposed mod-kill lol

That was my favorite moment of the game

"Buffy, she claimed can I claim?"

"You could try and see what happens"

"If Buffy is threatening me I think she's lying guys."

Darren Sanders @ 30/3/2017 0:59

Buffy @ 29/3/2017 22:24 Belated/special added HOL - Maddie's Really Old Guy claim and supposed mod-kill lol That was my favorite moment of the game "Buffy, she claimed can I claim?" "You could try and see what happens" "If Buffy is threatening me I think she's lying guys."

Seeing how upset you got in the moments before my lynch because I wasn't modkilled was my favorite moment in the game.

Wasn't really upset but once I saw your flip it was sorta an aha moment.

Great game Buffy thanks for running it

LOL- it was fun why I lasted and I'm glad I went out like a dog... primate's dog.

And I don't know about FE, but GLBers will use the gun 100%. Some just shoot someone, some ask for consensus, then shoot someone. But in the end, the gun is getting fired. Handing us a toy like that is too irresistible.

To be fair, I wasn't around at the end of the day (church) and I didn't think a couple of votes that early with so many inactives would necessitate really needing to advocate for why those votes were a bad idea. FE is notorious early in games for last minute swings early in the game.

However, my win condition simply said "you win when you roleblock ahoda for voting for you early and often so many games in a row" so technically I won N1 :)