Hall of Fame:

Herm- He lost his fellow mason, kept the posting up in his mason forum when he was the only one, recruited three solid recruits, all while appearing totally non-threatening to scum in the daily forum. If I hadn’t known he was mason, his scattered votes (sometimes on fellow masons) and his intentional arguing with fellow masons put a lot of distance there so that it would not have been obvious that he was aligned with them, let alone their leader. Even after he died, his posts in the graveyard showed he had a good handle on who was scum.

Spindoctor- He had the bad luck of having his rat-thing, Brown Jenkins, outted D2 by the failed mafia kill attempt the night before. Yet he somehow was able to appear non-threatening to the town so that they did not make a serious attempt to lynch him, despite many of the folks running into his rat. Cult helped argue that “in a normal game, spin couldn’t be a killer”, neglecting to mention that nothing was quite normal in this game.

Cult- Despite some bad luck, they did a great job of obfuscating themselves. While they felt they were obviously outted (and they were) they threw up a pretty good smokescreen so that they lived longer than they should have (and lead to a down to the wire heart pounder between Mercator vs Lamps). While many *wanted* Darren Sanders dead just to remove him, many felt he was still town. And nobody really suspected that cult would have a group action.

Timmah- Who didn’t push his initial win condition when he could have and then went on to win total victory by meeting *both* of his win conditions.

Free Candy- He continued on as the only mafia, taking down townie after townie alone, with many townies thinking he was a mason (until brian confirmed he was not). He finally was too quiet and got lynched.

Lamps: He got good results multiple times and struggled to get his info known and believed. The cult pushback led him near suicidal, but he pushed on to help the town win.

The rest of the town: You spent a lot of time confused and frustrated, especially confused, but you pulled together to win it.

Hall of Lame


Mafia: You had a bad run of it. Primate hit the granny N1, Helios and Christian were both picked off for being scummy early, and there wasn’t much you could do about it after that. The Helios and Christian lynches also helped the townies gain extra sanity early on, which made things that much harder for the cult as well.

Cult: I gave you tools to check on sanity to help with recruiting, but you never used it, instead thinking farlig sending a note that might never get there was more important. Farlig’s sanity at that time was so low that the note went not to ahoda as targeted but to the next closest role, which was inactive bocanuck. :rofl: You also revived the town RBer (who blocked one of your rituals) who also had investigative powers, which was dangerous to you. Probably safer going after someone else… ;)

did the cult have to revive anyone?

im317 @ 22/11/2016 12:21

did the cult have to revive anyone?

No. That was part of Canucks role and was optional. Probably wasn't the best idea looking back but was the easiest/only way he could really try to prove his role/buy town credit.

Reviving chris would have actually been very interesting, looking back

Sweet, no HoL

farlig @ 22/11/2016 13:24

im317 @ 22/11/2016 12:21 did the cult have to revive anyone? No. That was part of Canucks role and was optional. Probably wasn't the best idea looking back but was the easiest/only way he could really try to prove his role/buy town credit.

this was after Curtis was dead thought. Canuck was a logical candidate for cult once town knew how cult was recruited. it might have even been worth reviving known cult and getting Canuck lynched, but for sure it would have been better to not revive, or revive someone who couldn't hurt cult.

im317 @ 22/11/2016 15:56

farlig @ 22/11/2016 13:24 im317 @ 22/11/2016 12:21 did the cult have to revive anyone? No. That was part of Canucks role and was optional. Probably wasn't the best idea looking back but was the easiest/only way he could really try to prove his role/buy town credit. this was after Curtis was dead thought. Canuck was a logical candidate for cult once town knew how cult was recruited. it might have even been worth reviving known cult and getting Canuck lynched, but for sure it would have been better to not revive, or revive someone who couldn't hurt cult.

We were hoping she would turn into cult after the revive or soon after, because she should have had low sanity.

It's all on the hilarious Cult board which might become accessible sometime this week.

Winner winner chicken dinner!

Thanks vlady, it was fun!

"oh"