Eben (2/3) - Wikey, Badger
Badger (1/3) - Angi
Wikey (0/3) - Eben, Eben

Wikey never unlynched before he lynched Rose. so his vote on Rose never counted, but I forgot that he did unvote just now. So this should be the most updated:

Eben (1/3) - Wikey, Badger
Badger (1/3) - Angi
Wikey (0/3) - Eben, Eben

I've got 19 minutes until I place my vote, and right now It'll be going on Badger.

Lol you asked for my thoughts Wikey. I've already explained the same line of reasoning in this thread.

Buffy and Ari both completely ignored Eben except to call him town. I don't see them doing that unless they are on a scum faction because town BP really screws with them. Mafia Doc is Def a role they'do try to protect though, and it lines up with him surviving that attack just as well as him being BP. And Mafia Doc is a pretty common role IMO whereas Town BP is kinda rare.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 17/5/2016 15:12

Lol you asked for my thoughts Wikey. I've already explained the same line of reasoning in this thread. Buffy and Ari both completely ignored Eben except to call him town. I don't see them doing that unless they are on a scum faction because town BP really screws with them. Mafia Doc is Def a role they'do try to protect though, and it lines up with him surviving that attack just as well as him being BP. And Mafia Doc is a pretty common role IMO whereas Town BP is kinda rare.

Why would I have pushed Lamps (Godfather) to claim so aggressively? I did that because I knew I had (likely) the only town bullet proof role, and wanted to push for his claim.

Eben Etzebeth @ 17/5/2016 15:36

I feel like he would have said something about her! He didn't mention her at all..

I hate sitting on info because once I did and was killed

Eben Etzebeth @ 17/5/2016 15:14

BadgerMcBeaver @ 17/5/2016 15:12 Lol you asked for my thoughts Wikey. I've already explained the same line of reasoning in this thread. Buffy and Ari both completely ignored Eben except to call him town. I don't see them doing that unless they are on a scum faction because town BP really screws with them. Mafia Doc is Def a role they'do try to protect though, and it lines up with him surviving that attack just as well as him being BP. And Mafia Doc is a pretty common role IMO whereas Town BP is kinda rare. Why would I have pushed Lamps (Godfather) to claim so aggressively? I did that because I knew I had (likely) the only town bullet proof role, and wanted to push for his claim.

That's The reason I'm not 100% confident it's you and still considering another possibility. But I feel there's a lot of other stuff that points in the direction of you, and that could have been distancing?

I thought Rose was scummy until Eben posted a run down of Rose this game

##Unlynch
##Lynch Badger

Make me proud everybody once I log back on after practice! If not, see ya'll in the next day.

Angi @ 17/5/2016 15:20

I thought Rose was scummy until Eben posted a run down of Rose this game

Her list of good/bad guys was uncannily correct.. So there could be something to that. But I still think Dadd would have said something if she was bad. Seems as if she just kicked ass in her reads early on.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 17/5/2016 16:12

Lol you asked for my thoughts Wikey. I've already explained the same line of reasoning in this thread. Buffy and Ari both completely ignored Eben except to call him town. I don't see them doing that unless they are on a scum faction because town BP really screws with them. Mafia Doc is Def a role they'do try to protect though, and it lines up with him surviving that attack just as well as him being BP. And Mafia Doc is a pretty common role IMO whereas Town BP is kinda rare.

Scum would never have aggressively targeted Town BP lol Anyone that is almost cleared as town would never have been a day target for scum. They never threw shae on me either lol

Angi @ 17/5/2016 15:23

BadgerMcBeaver @ 17/5/2016 16:12 Lol you asked for my thoughts Wikey. I've already explained the same line of reasoning in this thread. Buffy and Ari both completely ignored Eben except to call him town. I don't see them doing that unless they are on a scum faction because town BP really screws with them. Mafia Doc is Def a role they'do try to protect though, and it lines up with him surviving that attack just as well as him being BP. And Mafia Doc is a pretty common role IMO whereas Town BP is kinda rare. Scum would never have aggressively targeted Town BP lol Anyone that is almost cleared as town would never have been a day target for scum. They never threw shae on me either lol

I've been pretty heavily targeted by scum as town BP before (I think it was the Xmas mafia hosted by Brian).

Town BP being around in the end game really screws up things for mafia. And it's not hard to get heat thrown on people who survive attacks. It's also the go to claim for Mafia that survive attacks.

I think Mafia could just as easily have seen that there was no way they were going to be able to convince anybody to lynch Eben given that his claim was watertight, which is maybe why they ignored him.

He was quick to get on Lamps case too. I remarked on it the next day because it stood out to me. It lines up with his claim.

Also, reading the posts immediately following your claim makes you look quite suspicious too Badger! After you made it, Buffy literally posted five minutes later to dispute it, and not too long later so did Ari.

Mafia disputing my claim is more likely to happen if I'm town than if I'm mafia. Especially with a weak claim like mine.

Also Ari pushed for my lynch like 4 days in a row. That's more than just distancing.