HOF

-Kiwi and DD. Their strategy might have had some flaws in it for sure, but you can't argue with the result. I thought for sure they were doomed and I think they even thought so as well. Kiwi's claim of Vanilla was probably the best he could have come up with because it was believable for a little bit. I really did like DD's claim too, but some of the details he gave with it were all over the place. Overall though, these are the winners and for overcoming so many obstacles, they deserve it!

-Gotta give it up to Christian. He may have been all over the place with his thoughts, but he was easily the most active townie and led the discussions throughout until he was killed. He was the most hardcore on DD and it's a shame that the town didn't listen to him. I never understood why he came off so scummy tbh and I still don't really understand it.

-Samm did really well too. If he would've survived the day he got lynched, then I would think he would win no matter what. All he had to do was be alive at the end and he got very close! With his role he had to lay low in the beginning, but not too low, and he was able to perfect it imo. His reads were also really spot on throughout.

-Wikey has lapses of activity but when he was here, he was very helpful. Its amazing the town couldn't pull this out with the amount of townies that were good toward the end. Him and Samm were the two most sensible people towards the end by far.

-Ari's reads were also good too. I remember he made a post where he literally named every scum person left (Animal, DD, Kiwi, Samm) as the people he suspected. He never gained much from his role though.

-Tricks played really well with his role as well. I thought for sure he would try hiding behind more people to clear them, but when he did he chose Animal and died. He was very helpful in discussions and was a big part in proving there was no mason traitor due to hiding behind the masons.

-Buffy had a lot of good ideas as the Godfather and overall did a good job blending in. I think if not for surviving an attack, she could've lasted a lot longer since no one was really looking at her.


HOL

-Sorry Herm, but I have to put you here. I was baffled at some of the decisions you made down the stretch. I think you probably know which ones I'm talking about so I don't want to keep bringing them up, but hopefully you learned from it! In a game setup where there was all very simple roles, you shouldn't believe that there was some apprentice role thrown out there randomly.

-The Mafia for killing Tricks not once, but twice in a row! You guys had multiple people listed as suspects to kill both nights, yet both nights you targeted Tricks, even AFTER the first time when he didn't die. I'm shocked none of you realized he was the hider when he was throwing out that he KNEW dr and Herm were town. I think that really set you guys back a lot but you were able to recover from it.

-CURT! Ugh, I was so happy when I saw you were the Cult Leader. And then....you didn't know you didn't have to recruit every night when it said it in your role (: you did manage to target more scum in one night than the whole town did the rest of the game tho so gj gj

-Animal. I thought some of your kill choices were good, while others were not so good. Killing Buffy twice in a row was unnecessary to me. The SK needs everyone dead to win, so if you think someone is mafia, you should want them around, especially with the amount of people that were still left when you targeted Buffy. It seemed like you just wanted the satisfaction of Buffy dying, but to me, you should've looked in a different direction after she survived the first time.

-Moose, I know you're still new to this, but that was really painful to watch. The only reason your fake claim worked was because the real doctor hadn't logged on from the time you claimed until the day ended. AND THEN YOUR TEAM KILLED THE REAL DOCTOR which was hilarious to me.

-Chris. Okay so Chris scanned Buffy night 1 and got an innocent scan. I can see why he thought she might've been town after that, but once she survived an attack, that should've triggered in your head right there what her role was after she scanned as town. I know Chris is new to all of this, but him trying to convince people she was town really had a bad affect and possibly could've helped Buffy survive the first lynch.

-Vernon refusing to use his role because it was stupid until the night before he died

-Craig basically coming out saying he killed Aries. The post you made made it obvious it was you buddy

-Cash Money tying the vote and causing a no lynch literally in the last 10 seconds of the day

-Shadow killing Angi literally as soon as he got the gun. It's not his fault since he got a guilty scan on her, but he had all game to use the gun and kind of "jumped the gun" with it in my opinion

Me killing Angi would have been a great move had i not died. I learned I was insane by doing that.

yeah, i dunno what else you'd expect a cop with a guilty report and a gun to do really...

I guess be psychic


The reason I wanted to use it asap was because I could die without getting the chance to strike at what I presumed was the mafia. And whatdouknow I died the next night anyway

the only time i've like ever been hof !

...I said I could see why you did it. But instead of killing her on the spot you could've waited and saw how others reacted to her to help get other intel as well if you got a guilty read on her. I'm not blaming you for shooting her, just the timing of it.

Vic Probst @ 9/1/2015 17:56

...I said I could see why you did it. But instead of killing her on the spot you could've waited and saw how others reacted to her to help get other intel as well if you got a guilty read on her. I'm not blaming you for shooting her, just the timing of it.

Could see why - HOL. If you couldn't see why then that would make HOL.
That is a different strategy I didn't want to do. In my mind I had a guilty scan and a gun and I didn't want to die without lowering their numbers. I didn't feel like I needed to gather intel on how people reacted to Angi because of my Role. My role was the best form of INTEL enough.

I know, I just meant you could've learned a lot about other people in the game "knowing that Angi was mafia." Like seeing how they reacted to her etc. Idk, I was just surprised you used it right on the spot.

Shadow @ 9/1/2015 17:58

Vic Probst @ 9/1/2015 17:56 ...I said I could see why you did it. But instead of killing her on the spot you could've waited and saw how others reacted to her to help get other intel as well if you got a guilty read on her. I'm not blaming you for shooting her, just the timing of it. Could see why - HOL. If you couldn't see why then that would make HOL. That is a different strategy I didn't want to do. In my mind I had a guilty scan and a gun and I didn't want to die without lowering their numbers. I didn't feel like I needed to gather intel on how people reacted to Angi because of my Role. My role was the best form of INTEL enough.

lol I'm not in HOL?

Greensday @ 9/1/2015 19:17

lol I'm not in HOL?

Same, I'm surprised Vic didn't just throw me in the HOL with the reason
"lol he's so awful he got killed twice in one night lol"

I mean fuck, I got our doc killed because I decided to claim a day too late

I forgot about Craig's post after killing Aries. It made me lol when I first read it.

I don't think it was that post that got Craig killed, but he was one of the ppl calling out Aries... and then Aries died so looked like he was either SK or Vig.

Vic I don't read my roles give me a break here