Wonder if Curtis and Shawn were bused and you got their info reverse? I know that makes zero sense but the whole thing makes zero sense lol

I wonder if Shawn will ever show up and try to provide some clarity or just drop a BS claim like Boc did yesterday.

I would think Shawn has to be scum since both Curtis and Vern flipped town.

Kru @ 10/11/2013 14:52

I saw him kill somebody.

Which one?

Yahhhhhhh this is confusing, I was pretty much sold on Curtis being scum so I'm really surprised he was killed and flipped town.

I guess I'll also wait for Shawn before lynching.

Curtis is always scum whether he's scum or not, it's a definitive rule

Also, I don't really understand your claim Korr? Are you claiming tracker lol, or like watcher, I'm really confused by it all.

I don't know who, just saw him killing.

So you Watched Shawn? Good enough for me. I'm leaving my vote on him then. There's only 1 plausible explanation but it can be easily countered.

Also while we're at it is there any other useful information you got while watching N1 or N2?

So just summarizing what was said on D2 and seeing how it makes sense or if we may be missing something.

- Dylan scanned Boc N1, scum.
- Dylan scanned Curtis N2, scum. He also scanned Shawn, town.
- Shawn claimed he visited Vernon, not Curtis, in N2.
- Vernon and Curtis die, both town.

Vernon was hider, but there's nothing about dying in case of hiding behind scum.

Could some bussing be involved? Curtis said at the end of D2 that bussing might not make sense. I guess it's possible that Vernon hid behind Curtis, but somehow Dylan scanned Shawn...? Plus Dylan = insane? Any other explanation for it?

I am confused about my readings. I got Boc's character and alignment right. But I got Curtis's character right but his alignment wrong.

But I also got Shawn as town, so I can't be paranoid (everyone is scum), but I also can't be insane because I got Boc right.

James Chen @ 10/11/2013 23:26

I am confused about my readings. I got Boc's character and alignment right. But I got Curtis's character right but his alignment wrong. But I also got Shawn as town, so I can't be paranoid (everyone is scum), but I also can't be insane because I got Boc right.

Shawn's character you saw was not by any chance Vernon's? Guess not but worth asking... maybe you're insane on even nights lol idk if that's done ever.

As I see it the results for Curtis where obviously bussed with someone mafia. Either by a town bus driver or a mafia one. Its entirely possible the mafia would want to try and frame Curtis (being a popular target for first nights) by bussing him with one of their own. For him to scan as mafia if someone would do so.

So lets look at the facts.

Dylan scans Boc as scum - true scan
Dylan scans Curtis as scum - false scan
Dylan scans Shawn as town - ???

Curtis was bussed with a mafia member, thus making him scan as mafia.

Shawn says he visited Vernon. Dylan sees Shawn visit Curtis by his scan. For Shawn to have visted Curtis, he would have to have been bussed with Vernon. Vernon is neither miller or mafia so that cant be true because of the scan results.

So Shawn has to be lying about visiting Vernon. There is no way for Curtis to falsely scan scum and for Shawn to have visited Vernon. Right? Am I missing something here?

its not Vernon's character no.