Spin @ 3/2/2021 15:53

Christian @ 3/2/2021 13:51 so Curtis as SK Spin for sure seems Mafia with the way he played the bomb thing today. and then either: Cody and Nav as mafia together OR Stargate is somehow still Mafia who has made up all of this information, which doesn't seem likely at this point. :P how else would Nav as claimed town vig have survived an attack from the SK? Nav had to claim something when Stargate said he saw him visiting Timmah. No counter since made it seem possible. Spin is definitely not mafia at all. This bullshit reasoning makes me think you are mafia trying to get me easily lynched.

k.

Why on Earth would I counter-claim Curtis if I was mafia?

Christian @ 3/2/2021 14:44

Unfortunately (for Curtis) I think we gain the most information from Curtis' lynch.

On the contrary, I’ll actually be dying with my info and you’ll only learn that I am in fact SK (:

AhrNav @ 3/2/2021 15:55

Christian @ 3/2/2021 11:51 so Curtis as SK Spin for sure seems Mafia with the way he played the bomb thing today. and then either: Cody and Nav as mafia together OR Stargate is somehow still Mafia who has made up all of this information, which doesn't seem likely at this point. :P how else would Nav as claimed town vig have survived an attack from the SK? Nav had to claim something when Stargate said he saw him visiting Timmah. No counter since made it seem possible. this seems really hard trying to fit a square peg in a round hole if im Mafia who was the 3rd killer on N1 and why havent they counterclaimed me

I don't know. I'm trying to wrap my head around all of it.
Your kill targets seem like you are what you say you are. You say you didn't survive an attack. But Stargate saw a killer visit you. Stargate claims that HE survived a kill attempt, and that the doctor (at least the town doc) was not on you.

Curtis @ 3/2/2021 15:58

Christian @ 3/2/2021 14:44 Unfortunately (for Curtis) I think we gain the most information from Curtis' lynch. On the contrary, I’ll actually be dying with my info and you’ll only learn that I am in fact SK (:

we just need to know if you have any other abilities besides killing.

Spin @ 3/2/2021 15:57

Why on Earth would I counter-claim Curtis if I was mafia?

because you just tried to blow him up that way you tried to blow up. lol

before that, I wasn't reading you as scum, Spin. All of that came from the way you played this day. That is all.

if I die soon, I'll be happy to not have to figure out what's going on around here.

##Lynch Curtis

Christian @ 3/2/2021 14:59

Curtis @ 3/2/2021 15:58 Christian @ 3/2/2021 14:44 Unfortunately (for Curtis) I think we gain the most information from Curtis' lynch. On the contrary, I’ll actually be dying with my info and you’ll only learn that I am in fact SK (: we just need to know if you have any other abilities besides killing.

I sure don’t

Christian @ 3/2/2021 14:00

before that, I wasn't reading you as scum, Spin. All of that came from the way you played this day. That is all.

For as long as I've played mafia, I've found it scummier to ask for suggestions and then kill people based on those suggestions in situations like this, because then you pass the responsibilities of the choice onto others. I told people I had a bomb, I asked for comments, and then I picked a target of my choosing who I thought likely to be scum, and I hit a target that by their own admission is not Town.

You can have issues with how it was played, but at the end of the day, I helped town move closer to meeting their win condition. If that makes me scum, so be it.

Spin @ 3/2/2021 15:06

For as long as I've played mafia, I've found it scummier to ask for suggestions and then kill people based on those suggestions in situations like this, because then you pass the responsibilities of the choice onto others.

lol this is literally exactly what you did

Curtis @ 3/2/2021 14:11

Spin @ 3/2/2021 15:06 For as long as I've played mafia, I've found it scummier to ask for suggestions and then kill people based on those suggestions in situations like this, because then you pass the responsibilities of the choice onto others. lol this is literally exactly what you did

If I did exactly that, I would have bombed Cody or Reaper, as they were the top choices on the most lists.

You quoted me and then made your choice lol.

you also didn't tell the person they were about to get blown up. They didn't have a chance to defend themselves or even offer a claim.

Did it work out? Sure. Did you help Town? Sure. Did you help Mafia? Sure. So why can't you still be Mafia?

I was the victim of a dumb crime!