Ok. Now time to contribute.

I agree Jeff is a strong choice. I thought day 2 he was clear fairly because of the single kill but Henry's self doctor role seems to imply otherwise.

A vig will often take out non-talkers because that's where the scum usually hide and overall a more talkative game is more fun (again I apologise for shrugging off the game this long)

If Jeff is the don he'll scan vanilla so claiming that means scanning won't help here and we really have all the info we can glean from him without him spilling any more beans.

And really I just dislike unnecessary role claiming. It just muddles up the game and makes it boring.

So we'll lynch him, because he can take it. Because he's not our active. He's a silent contributer, a self-interest protector. A vanilla knight.

##lynch: Jeff

LSFissue @ 18/2/2013 21:52

because ari is cool

Thats right

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 18/2/2013 22:59

I am still a bit wary on a jeff lynch, but the fact that he has absolutely nothing at all to say makes me lean a bit towards stinging him up by the neck. I'll give him a chance for now though. In the meanwhile ##lynch Vernon For just jumping around on various random trains. If we've all decided that metagaming is all the rage today, when Vernon is scum he tends to just dick around and lynch randomly because hurrr hurrr hurrr joaks. When he's town, he actually sticks to his guns on his apparently random lynches. Lynching Greenday round 1 could have just been an attemptto deflect that they were on the same side (or because he forgot they were scummates, which happens). I'd like to see the people who haven't actually contributed any thoughts to start though. Grim, LSFissue (I don't care if you're new, Alex, you play epicmafia enough to know how this works), Dylan, Justin and Jeff, I'm looking at you guys!

Wut? Wut? Wut?

Why lynch the guy that was trying to lynch Greenday before Rob claimed? You REALLY REALLY think Vernon is the mastermind behind some mafia plan that would make him look good? I dont think so. Makes me kinda think you are scum trying to vote off some easy vernon. SURE he is trigger happy and pretty aggressive and silly but I really dont think he would hatch the plan you are accusing him of.

Malion is being cringey as fuck. I smell mafia on him all the way to snowland. DR smells a lot like mafia with that lynch vote aswell. Anyone remember that DR train that suddenly headed for Panda day 1? Both Malion and Greenday where on that.....

If I was mafia and in Drrr's position and Rito came after me after endless amounts of retardation and vote switching then I would be pretty pissed and would've made that exact post that Drrr did in order to place tons and tons of doubt into all of Rito's already awful theories. That way everyone would feel stupid for even considering following his lead

HOWEVER, if I was in Drrr's position and was town then I would be equally annoyed that he came after me and might've done the same thing she just did in order to make fun of him

HOWEVER AGAIN, it's interesting to note that of all the many people that Rito has lynched so far, Drrr is the only one to act extremely defensive to his silly accusations

Cringey? Like cringe-worthy?

I will admit that dark knight joke was a stretch.

Ari @ 18/2/2013 18:28

LSFissue @ 18/2/2013 21:52 because ari is cool Thats right Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 18/2/2013 22:59 I am still a bit wary on a jeff lynch, but the fact that he has absolutely nothing at all to say makes me lean a bit towards stinging him up by the neck. I'll give him a chance for now though. In the meanwhile ##lynch Vernon For just jumping around on various random trains. If we've all decided that metagaming is all the rage today, when Vernon is scum he tends to just dick around and lynch randomly because hurrr hurrr hurrr joaks. When he's town, he actually sticks to his guns on his apparently random lynches. Lynching Greenday round 1 could have just been an attemptto deflect that they were on the same side (or because he forgot they were scummates, which happens). I'd like to see the people who haven't actually contributed any thoughts to start though. Grim, LSFissue (I don't care if you're new, Alex, you play epicmafia enough to know how this works), Dylan, Justin and Jeff, I'm looking at you guys! Wut? Wut? Wut? Why lynch the guy that was trying to lynch Greenday before Rob claimed? You REALLY REALLY think Vernon is the mastermind behind some mafia plan that would make him look good? I dont think so. Makes me kinda think you are scum trying to vote off some easy vernon. SURE he is trigger happy and pretty aggressive and silly but I really dont think he would hatch the plan you are accusing him of. Malion is being cringey as fuck. I smell mafia on him all the way to snowland. DR smells a lot like mafia with that lynch vote aswell. Anyone remember that DR train that suddenly headed for Panda day 1? Both Malion and Greenday where on that.....

Vernon jumped on greenday before there was ANY evidence. During the day 1 joaky-joaks fest. There was absolutely no reason why.

Then on day 2 he decided to vote Greenday again, for absolutely no reason. When the lynch started to take off, however, he switched to Rob. He also lynched Boc in there somewhere for "lurking" when boc had posted just a little while before and had been active all game.

Vernon is a smarter player than you give him credit for, and claiming "oh he's just retarded" is ridiculous. You really don't believe a mafia member would lynch one of their own before there was a genuine train against them?

rose you seem mad bro

I'm not acting defensive. I'm acting annoyed that this is like the 4th time I'vebeen accused ofbeing scum because I'm excited to play. I've been debating lynching Vernon for his enless train of switching votes and disinterest in actually contributing beyond mirroring who every other player says is suspicious for a while. He isn't trying to actually detect scum. He's trying to slide by.

my boc vote was a joke.
if I voted for henry that was a joke too.
my vote for greenday was originally based on pre-game thoughts where I find scum. keep in mind. I have the best record in mafia on this site, and have voted for more scum than ANY of you. probably by 2-3 times the amount, too.
i switched to rob after a greenday vote formed because the train for greenday scared me and I thought rob was pulling a fast one. maybe he still is.
i voted for grim as a joke because her post annoyed me and I think she could be scum.
and now i voted for rose because i sensed something.

In their defense you were metagaming too.

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 18:39

rose you seem mad bro

Helios is not here. I have to take up the mantle.

That was at Rose

stop interrupting my posts >:(

I'll be gone for the rest of the day. see ya.

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 18:41

i switched to rob after a greenday vote formed because the train for greenday scared me and I thought rob was pulling a fast one. maybe he still is.

Tell me why would Rob would out himself as a cop and kill a fellow mafia member after pushing for him all day long before there was any other push for him on day 2 after only one town player was down.

Please explain that to me.

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 18:41

keep in mind. I have the best record in mafia on this site, and have voted for more scum than ANY of you. probably by 2-3 times the amount, too.

lol'd. You have voted for more players than any of us, probably by 2-3 times the amount! There's an enormous difference. And when you happen to be right about someone due to luck, your previous actions are always so poor that you're incapable of forming any sort of argument to support it and aren't able to get anyone to follow you. Your record for actually successfully getting someone lynched is probably quite poor