Penner @ 11/3/2021 23:08

AhrNav @ 11/3/2021 21:43 Thisisbourbon @ 11/3/2021 18:41 Thank you to whoever decided to role block me last night. Thank you to whoever TRIED to role block me last night Two ppl roleblocked? Guessing one is a scum target and one is a town target

IMO Nav is most likely a scum target. He claimed having a town power role day 1.

Farlig sounds like a target for a town roleblocker that was undecided on what to do and went with their gut.

Speaking of farlig, he made it to day 2 alive! 🥳🥳🥳

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:51

And if scum does scapegoat me based on this and I get lynched you will have info to work with after I flip town.

Trying to decide right now if this line of reasoning might apply to Spin.

I'm unsure because I do think it's reasonable that a townie might arrive at this conclusion. But I kinda offered myself up as an easy scapegoat for scum and he hopped on board pretty quickly.

Town roleblocker going for Farlig is a weird choice. Someone on the Nav train would’ve been a better option imo

As much as I loved Marnu, things just didn't feel right without my eyeroll avatar. So glad to have it back!

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:20

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:51 And if scum does scapegoat me based on this and I get lynched you will have info to work with after I flip town. Trying to decide right now if this line of reasoning might apply to Spin. I'm unsure because I do think it's reasonable that a townie might arrive at this conclusion. But I kinda offered myself up as an easy scapegoat for scum and he hopped on board pretty quickly.

First I don’t get that you’d be suspected for getting the walkie. That logic doesn’t make sense to me.

However, that’s not an unusual spin question to ask so I don’t really get a scum read from spin just because he brought it up.

Penner @ 12/3/2021 0:21

Town roleblocker going for Farlig is a weird choice. Someone on the Nav train would’ve been a better option imo

I kinda view Farlig as erratic (sorry Farlig) so if I was roleblocker and I had no leads, I might have considered him an option.

Also, if we're operating under the assumption that someone on the Nav train would be a better option... Nav himself would have been the worst possible option based on that logic, no?

I just don't see a town roleblocker blocking Nav after claiming a power town role night 1.

At no point did I ever say Badger was scum. I actually have Badger as pretty solid town for me. I posed the question to see people's responses.

Reading comprehension is pretty tough in this crowd.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:24

Penner @ 12/3/2021 0:21 Town roleblocker going for Farlig is a weird choice. Someone on the Nav train would’ve been a better option imo I kinda view Farlig as erratic (sorry Farlig) so if I was roleblocker and I had no leads, I might have considered him an option. Also, if we're operating under the assumption that someone on the Nav train would be a better option... Nav himself would have been the worst possible option based on that logic, no? I just don't see a town roleblocker blocking Nav after claiming a power town role night 1.

Well good thing Nav wasn’t on the Nav train and I’m absolutely wasnt talking about him at all

I think if Badger did get the walkie, then Badger isn't scum, because scum would want Lamps alive and could somewhat clear a member via Lamps.

Timmah @ 12/3/2021 0:24

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:20 BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:51 And if scum does scapegoat me based on this and I get lynched you will have info to work with after I flip town. Trying to decide right now if this line of reasoning might apply to Spin. I'm unsure because I do think it's reasonable that a townie might arrive at this conclusion. But I kinda offered myself up as an easy scapegoat for scum and he hopped on board pretty quickly. First I don’t get that you’d be suspected for getting the walkie. That logic doesn’t make sense to me. However, that’s not an unusual spin question to ask so I don’t really get a scum read from spin just because he brought it up.

Timmah @ 12/3/2021 0:24

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:20 BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 23:51 And if scum does scapegoat me based on this and I get lynched you will have info to work with after I flip town. Trying to decide right now if this line of reasoning might apply to Spin. I'm unsure because I do think it's reasonable that a townie might arrive at this conclusion. But I kinda offered myself up as an easy scapegoat for scum and he hopped on board pretty quickly. First I don’t get that you’d be suspected for getting the walkie. That logic doesn’t make sense to me. However, that’s not an unusual spin question to ask so I don’t really get a scum read from spin just because he brought it up.

I think the logic is that I was dumb enough to be like "LAMPS HAS MADE A FORUM WITH ME AND WE CAN KILL HIM NOW" without considering how much leverage I would had with him after he put me in that position. I was a little concerned people might have that reaction before I admitted receiving the walkie talkie.

I'm not sold on Spin being scum. He might have been scum just looking for an easy target, but he might have also been town thinking out loud. Still though, there's part of me that think he's better at scumhunting than that?

Ugh I hate that we can't edit posts because that double quote hurts my eyes lol.

I literally just slapped my forehead so hard my wife asked if everything was ok from the other room.

It's pretty telling that I ask a question to get responses, and it immediately shifts to "spin is scum for even thinking this".

BadgerMcBeaver @ 11/3/2021 22:24

I just don't see a town roleblocker blocking Nav after claiming a power town role night 1.

If the town roleblocker didn't believe the Town part of the claim, then I could see it being possible. Unlikely, but possible.